E
ender
Guest
McG asked me to post a new topic about an incident which occured on my QL2 (last year)
While on the 13k march, a master corpral was encouraging a candidate. Said candidate got sick of the Mcpl talking to her, and told him to shut the f*** up. The only disiplinary action that was taken was that she did fire picket for part of the course party.
I really think a line was crossed there. There are some things you shouldn‘t be able to get away with. On this course, the instructers were not allowed to assign push-ups because ‘‘PT is not to be used as a disiplinary tool". I really think that this is crap, and doesn‘t prepare anyone for future course (ie. QL3 in Gagetown) or anything in the army.
Another thing that concerns me is a person without functional english skills who managed to pass recruiting and QL3. It isn‘t clear whether this person doesn‘t understand orders, or deliberatly disobeys them. This person is a danger to everyone, especially when working with explosives/live ammunition.
I do think that if someone screws up accidently, they should be given a second chance.
But some people do these things repeatedly and out of thier own will. So when is the line crossed, and what can be done about it if it is.
While on the 13k march, a master corpral was encouraging a candidate. Said candidate got sick of the Mcpl talking to her, and told him to shut the f*** up. The only disiplinary action that was taken was that she did fire picket for part of the course party.
I really think a line was crossed there. There are some things you shouldn‘t be able to get away with. On this course, the instructers were not allowed to assign push-ups because ‘‘PT is not to be used as a disiplinary tool". I really think that this is crap, and doesn‘t prepare anyone for future course (ie. QL3 in Gagetown) or anything in the army.
Another thing that concerns me is a person without functional english skills who managed to pass recruiting and QL3. It isn‘t clear whether this person doesn‘t understand orders, or deliberatly disobeys them. This person is a danger to everyone, especially when working with explosives/live ammunition.
I do think that if someone screws up accidently, they should be given a second chance.
But some people do these things repeatedly and out of thier own will. So when is the line crossed, and what can be done about it if it is.