• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

1917

a_majoor

Army.ca Legend
Reaction score
30
Points
560
Saw 1917, and was impressed by the technical prowess of the director in making the film appear to be a "single shot" (like "Russian ArK". However, I found the story to be somewhat lacking, and felt little connection to the characters. In many ways, it was like watching the greatest training movie ever.

Still enjoyed the experience.
 

tomahawk6

Army.ca Legend
Reaction score
62
Points
530
I saw the film but wasn't wowed by it. Fast and furious is better.
 

BeyondTheNow

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Mentor
Reaction score
6
Points
530
The set design and attention to detail was incredible, in addition to the cinematography.

Character development was minimal, but understandable given the focus of the plot. Nothing was lost in terms of what was expected once the first few minutes played out—the viewer finds out what the purpose is going to be for the characters, and that’s it. The simplicity is underrated.

It’s unusual to use the word beautiful to describe aspects of a “war” movie; but then again, this wasn’t necessarily a movie about war.

 

The Bread Guy

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Subscriber
Donor
Reaction score
2,143
Points
1,260
Thucydides said:
Saw 1917, and was impressed by the technical prowess of the director in making the film appear to be a "single shot" (like "Russian ArK".
Another WW1 (truly) single-shot movie about Canadians was "21 Brothers" -- that one felt more like a stage play unfolding on screen.
 

NavyShooter

Army.ca Veteran
Subscriber
Reaction score
1,147
Points
1,090
The premise of the tale and how it all played out was perhaps less than 100% believable, but as a tale, it was told well, and the cinema was very good.

I would consider going back to see it in IMAX.  And I seldom view movies in theater, let alone going to see them twice.

NS
 

Journeyman

Army.ca Legend
Subscriber
Reaction score
1,025
Points
940
tomahawk6 said:
I saw the film but wasn't wowed by it. Fast and furious is better.
Absolutely.  'Fast and Furious' is one of the best movies out there, within the category of "Military Literature and Film."  :nod:
 

mariomike

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Subscriber
Mentor
Reaction score
607
Points
1,260
Blackadder1916 said:

That's where my grandfather was wounded with the Canadian Expeditionary Force (CEF) in 1917.

''I died in hell - They called it Passchendaele''.

Siegfried Sassoon.

 

BeyondTheNow

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Mentor
Reaction score
6
Points
530
NavyShooter said:
The premise of the tale and how it all played out was perhaps less than 100% believable, but as a tale, it was told well, and the cinema was very good...

Yes. For those unfamiliar, this article sheds light on inspiration for the film.

I neglected to mention scoring also. ‘Perfect complement to the scenes of building suspense (much like Dunkirk) and action sequences.

Is 1917 a true story? First World War background and historical accuracy of the Oscar-nominated Sam Mendes film

The film takes place during Operation Alberich, a German military withdrawal to stronger positions in northern France...

... 1917 is something of a true story, loosely based on a tale the director's grandfather - Alfred H. Mendes, who served with the British Army during the First World War - told him as a child.

The film takes place in April of 1917 during Operation Alberich - a historically accurate German military withdrawal to stronger positions in northern France.

"The story of 1917 was inspired not only by my own family history, but also by many others," the latter day Mendes told genealogy company Ancestry, who delved into the events of the film and uncovered the military records of the director’s grandfather.

Alfred Mendes was a man of small stature, and so was chosen to be a messenger on the Western Front due to the relative nimbleness his slight frame allowed.

He was awarded the Military Medal after he volunteered for a dangerous mission to locate injured soldiers scattered across No-Mans Land during the Battle of Passchendaele.

"I hope very much that the stories of those that came before us and fought on our behalf live on in our movie,” said Sam Mendes.

1917 also has real life connections to lead actor George MacKay, whose character in the film is tasked with delivering a message deep in enemy territory.

That's a mission not too dissimilar from one MacKay’s three times great uncle, Albert Victor Baulk, undertook himself.

Albert was a signaller for the 196th Siege Battery in Sailly-au-Bois, France, just a few miles from the German front lines where Operation Alberich took place

As a signaller and telephonist, Albert would have helped relay crucial communications to his unit, just like MacKay’s character.

When the Germans withdrew, Albert’s unit subsequently mobilised and attacked the enemy’s position at Arras, providing artillery fire to support attacking troops.

The war diary for his unit notes the following:

"196 SB [Siege Battery] Task – bombardment of trenches and strong points ahead of RFA [Royal Field Artillery] barrage, concluding with a creeping barrage covering advance of 4th Dragoons along SCARPE Valley."

More at link:

https://inews.co.uk/culture/film/1917-true-story-film-historical-accuracy-first-world-war-sam-mendes-1358467
 

mariomike

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Subscriber
Mentor
Reaction score
607
Points
1,260
NavyShooter said:
I seldom view movies in theater,

Neither do I, anymore.

I used to love going to our local theatre. It was in the village within walking distance from the house. It was one of those old "atmospheric" movie palaces that transported you to an exotic place, even before the picture started. It had an "open air" feeling. The ceiling was painted sky blue, Tiny light bulbs resembled stars. Images were projected to create a cloud-like effect. As if you were in a forest under a night sky. The interior walls were Spanish style, with ivory stucco and gold leaf. Uniformed ushers.

It closed in 1999 and was turned into a drug store.

Haven't seen 1917 yet, but guess I'll get around to it.

 
Top