- Reaction score
- 4,292
- Points
- 1,160
This, from the Financial Times, is yet another blow to the US Intelligence Community's credibility with allies:
http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/b1063cf0-0369-11e4-9195-00144feab7de.html?siteedition=intl#axzz36WjfST4p
This is a blunder because, just last year, in the wake of the Snowden fiasco, President Obama apologized to Chancellor Merkel for intercepting her calls and promised it was over; maybe he's kept that promise, but even if he did he should have told his officials to wrap up operations against the Germans, for a while at least ... maybe he did that, too, and they just ignored him. In any event the US looks both two-faced and a bit amateurish.
No one should be surprised that allies spy on one another, but they ought to do it with a bit more discretion.
http://www.ft.com/intl/cms/s/0/b1063cf0-0369-11e4-9195-00144feab7de.html?siteedition=intl#axzz36WjfST4p
Germany arrests US double agent, reports claim
By Jeevan Vasagar in Berlin
July 4, 2014
German authorities have arrested a suspected double agent working for the US who is thought to have spied on the Bundestag’s inquiry into claims of US surveillance, according to local media reports.
The incident risks becoming the biggest problem to hit US-German relations since it emerged in October last year that the US National Security Agency monitored the mobile phone of German chancellor Angela Merkel.
In a statement, Germany’s federal attorney-general said a 31-year-old German national had been arrested on Wednesday.
The statement said the man, who is being held in custody, is suspected of working for a foreign intelligence agency.
The claims that the arrested BND employee was a US spy were first reported in the Süddeutsche Zeitung and by the broadcasters NDR and WDR. Spiegel Online reported that the man worked in the mailroom of the BND, Germany’s foreign intelligence agency.
Bild reported that the man had stolen documents over a two-year period, and sold them.
A German politician who had been briefed on the arrest said on Friday that it had not been definitively established that the US was the foreign power responsible. He warned against assuming that the case is a “one-sided story”.
The German parliamentary committee investigating the NSA said on Thursday it would adjourn to discuss the arrest.
The inquiry, which is looking at the scope of US spying on Germans’ communications, including the tapping of Ms Merkel’s phone, heard testimony from former NSA officials William Binney and Thomas Drake this week.
Members of the inquiry committee are conscious of the security risks involved and are using secure phones that encrypt calls to shield themselves from eavesdropping.
The chairman of the committee Patrick Sensburg said he was unable to comment on confidential parliamentary discussions.
He told the Financial Times: “Of course we think about protecting our communications. We leave our mobiles outside the room where we speak, and each of us has a safe in our offices where we keep notes and documents locked up.”
Ms Merkel’s spokesman said on Friday that she had been informed of the arrest, but declined to comment on reports that the man was an employee of the BND. The spokesman said the matter was “very serious”.
The chancellor’s spokesman declined to say whether the matter was discussed in a telephone call between Ms Merkel and President Barack Obama on Thursday.
Christian Flisek, a Social Democrat member of the Bundestag committee, said: “If this suspicion proves correct, it undermines the [transatlantic] trust that we have worked for months to restore, and is an attack on a German constitutional body.”
Martina Renner, a member of the opposition party Die Linke who also sits on the Bundestag committee, said she expected there would be “political consequences”.
Ms Renner said: “The federal government has to place more importance on protecting the fundamental rights of citizens, than the interests of German and US intelligence agencies.”
Last week, Germany announced that it had terminated a contract with Verizon over concerns about the security of its systems in the first sign of serious commercial repercussions in Europe from the NSA revelations.
On the whole, relations between the US and German governments have calmed down in recent months, after the row over the tapping of Ms Merkel’s phone last year.
Both sides have been keen to downplay the level of discord. In an interview with German state broadcaster ZDF in January, Mr Obama emphasised his “relationship of friendship and trust” with the German leader. The two governments have sought to work together over the Ukraine crisis.
The relationship has been complicated by the threat of German criminal proceedings against the NSA.
Germany’s federal prosecutor Harald Range said last month there was sufficient factual evidence that “unknown members of US intelligence services” had spied on the German chancellor’s mobile to launch an investigation.
At the same time, the prosecutor said there were no plans to look into the wider gathering of telecommunications data by “British and US intelligence agencies”.
BND was not immediately available for comment on the arrest. As a rule, Germany’s security agency does not comment on ongoing criminal inquiries.
This is a blunder because, just last year, in the wake of the Snowden fiasco, President Obama apologized to Chancellor Merkel for intercepting her calls and promised it was over; maybe he's kept that promise, but even if he did he should have told his officials to wrap up operations against the Germans, for a while at least ... maybe he did that, too, and they just ignored him. In any event the US looks both two-faced and a bit amateurish.
No one should be surprised that allies spy on one another, but they ought to do it with a bit more discretion.
